Feed sellers in China routinely use protein substitute

Feed sellers in China routinely use protein substitute

American food safety regulators trying to figure out how an industrial
chemical called melamine contaminated so much pet food in the United
States might come to this heavily polluted city in Shandong Province in
the northern part of the country.
Here at the Shandong Mingshui Great Chemical Group factory, huge boiler
vats are turning coal into melamine, which is used to create plastics and
But the leftover melamine scrap, small acorn-sized chunks of white rock,
is then being sold to local entrepreneurs, who say they secretly mix a
powdered form of the scrap into animal feed to artificially enhance the
protein level.

The melamine powder has been dubbed "fake protein" and is used to deceive
those who raise animals into thinking they are buying feed that provides
higher nutrition value.

"It just saves money," says a manager at an animal feed factory here.
"Melamine scrap is added to animal feed to boost the protein level."
The practice is widespread in China. For years animal feed sellers have
been able to cheat buyers by blending the powder into feed with little
regulatory supervision, according to interviews with melamine scrap
traders and agricultural workers here.
But now, melamine is at the center of a massive, multinational pet food
recall after it was linked earlier this month to the deaths and injuries
of thousands of cats and dogs in the United States and South Africa.
No one knows exactly how melamine - which had not been believed to be
particularly toxic - became so fatal in pet food, but its presence in
any form of American food is illegal.
U.S. regulators are now headed to China to figure out why pet food
ingredients imported from here, including wheat gluten, were contaminated
with high levels of the chemical.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has banned imports of wheat gluten
from China and ordered the recall of over 60 million packages of pet food.
And last week, the agency opened a criminal investigation in the case and
searched the offices of at least one pet food supplier.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture also stepped in Thursday, ordering more
than 6,000 hogs to be quarantined or slaughtered after some of the pet
food ingredients laced with melamine were accidentally sent to hog farms
in eight states, including California.
Scientists are now trying to determine whether melamine could be harmful
to human health.
The huge pet food recall is raising questions in the United States about
regulatory controls at a time when food supplies are increasingly being
sourced globally. Some experts complain that the FDA is understaffed and
underfunded, making it incapable of safeguarding America's food supply.
"They have fewer people inspecting product at the ports than ever before,"
says Caroline Smith DeWaal, director of food safety for the Center for
Science in the Public Interest in Washington. "Until China gets programs
in place to verify the safety of their products, they need to be inspected
by U.S. inspectors. This open-door policy on food ingredients is an open
invitation for an attack on the food supply, either intentional or unintentional."
The pet food case is also putting China's agricultural exports under
greater scrutiny because the country's dubious food safety record and
history of excessive antibiotic and pesticide use.

In recent years, for instance, China's food safety scandals have involved
everything from fake baby milk formulas and soy sauce made from human
hair, to instances where cuttlefish were soaked in calligraphy ink to
improve their color and eels were fed contraceptive pills to make them
grow long and slim.
China's government disputes any suggestion that melamine from the country
could have killed pets. But Friday, regulators here banned the use of
melamine in vegetable proteins made for export or for use in domestic food
Yet it is clear from visiting this region of northern China is that for
years melamine has been quietly mixed into Chinese animal feed and then
sold to unsuspecting farmers as protein-rich pig, poultry and fish feed.
Many animal feed operators advertise on the Internet seeking to purchase
melamine scrap. And melamine scrap producers and traders said in recent
interviews that they often sell to animal feed makers.
"Many companies buy melamine scrap to make animal feed, such as fish
feed," says Ji Denghui, general manager of the Fujian Sanming Dinghui
Chemical Company. "I don't know if there's a regulation on it. Probably
not. No law or regulation says 'don't do it,' so everyone's doing it. The
laws in China are like that, aren't they? If there's no accident, there
won't be any regulation."
Most local feed companies do not admit that they use melamine. But last
Friday here in Zhangqiu, a fast-growing industrial city southeast of
Beijing, a pair of animal feed producers explained in great detail how
they purchase low-grade wheat, corn, soybean or other proteins and then
mix in small portions of nitrogen-rich melamine, whose chemical properties
give a bag of animal feed an inflated protein level under standard tests.
Melamine is the new scam of choice, they say, because urea - another
nitrogen-rich chemical that works similarly - is illegal for use in pig
and poultry feed and can be easily tested for in China as well as the
United States.
"If you add it in small quantities, it won't hurt the animals," said one
animal feed entrepreneur whose name is being withheld to protect him from
The man - who works in a small animal feed operation that consists of a
handful of storage and mixing areas - said he has mixed melamine into
animal feed for years.
He said he was not currently using melamine, which is actually made from
urea. But he then pulled out a plastic bag containing what he said was
melamine powder and said he could dye it any color.
Asked whether he could create an animal feed and melamine brew, he said
yes, he has access to huge supplies of melamine. Using melamine-spiked pet
food ingredient was not a problem, he said, even thought the product would
be weak in protein.
"Pets are not like pigs or chickens," he said casually, explaining that
cheating them on protein won't matter. "They don't need to grow fast."
The feed seller makes a heftier profit because the substitute melamine
scrap is much cheaper than purchasing soy, wheat or corn protein.
"It's true you can make a lot more profit by putting melamine in," said a
second animal feed seller here in Zhangqiu. "Melamine will cost you about
$1.20 per ton for each protein count whereas real protein costs you about
$6, so you can see the difference."

Few people outside of agriculture know about melamine here. The Chinese
media, which is strictly censored, has not reported much about melamine or
the pet food recall overseas. And no one in agriculture here seems to
believe that melamine is particularly harmful to animals or pets in small
A man named Jing, who works in the sales department at the Shandong
Mingshui Great Chemical Group, said Friday that melamine scrap prices had
been rising but he was not aware of how the company's product was being
"We have an auction for melamine scrap every three months," he said. "I
haven't heard of it being added to animal feed. It's not for animal feed."

David Barboza reported from Zhangqiu and Alexei Barrionuevo reported from
Chicago. Rujun Shen also contributed reporting.
By David Barboza and Alexei Barrionuevo
The New York Times
Sunday, April 29, 2007